Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Clams & Chips
3pc.fish & Chip Meal
Breaded Shrimp & Chips
12pc. Shrimp & Chips
About
Captain Arthur's
Welcome to the culinary treasure that is Captain Arthur's, a beloved gem situated at 4451 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH. This delightful establishment has garnered a reputation for serving some of the finest seafood and comfort food the area has to offer, making it a crucial stop for anyone in pursuit of delicious eats.
Famed for its wide variety of platters, Captain Arthur's excels in providing options that cater to seafood lovers and fried food aficionados alike. Guests can indulge in the mouthwatering Fish & Clams Platter, Seafood Platters, or the comforting Chicken & Shrimp Platter. The Sampler Platter is ideal for those who want to experience a little bit of everything. For sandwich aficionados, the delectable Fish Sandwich and Chicken Sandwich are must-tries that promise to tantalize your taste buds.
Beyond the delectable seafood offerings, Captain Arthur's also shines with its breaded meals. The Clams & Chips and Breaded Shrimp & Chips provide a crunchy, satisfying experience that pairs perfectly with their famous coleslaw and hushpuppies, noted by customers like Ralph S. for being the best in the area.
It’s not just the food that keeps patrons coming back; Captain Arthur's boasts a level of hospitality that makes every visit memorable. Customers like Rodney Skeen have lauded the friendly and attentive staff, emphasizing the sense of community that permeates the atmosphere. Rebecca Lovejoy highlights not just the great food but also the cleanliness of the establishment, a testament to the care and quality that goes into every aspect of the dining experience.
While reviews hail from across state lines, reiterating the drive-worthy nature of this restaurant, the heart of Captain Arthur's lies in its commitment to serving great food with pride. Whether you're there for the crunchy hushpuppies, the perfectly fried fish, or simply to enjoy a meal among friends, each visit feels like an uplifting experience.
In a world filled with culinary options, Captain Arthur's stands out as a beacon for those seeking authentic and delicious seafood. With a menu that swings from classic to innovative, this local business is one worth supporting. Don't miss your chance to enjoy this slice of Youngstown’s food scene; your stomach will thank you!
For inquiries or to plan your visit, call them at +1 330-792-6764.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Best fish and chips, seafood, coleslaw and hushpuppies in the whole area! An absolute gem of a spot! ”
“ My route is primarily in Austintown on Tuesdays and I make sure that I close enough to this establishment to take my lunch every week. I worked at Arthur Treachers in high school. Loved the food and this is very close to what I remember. The staff and owners are top notch people and I never leave hungry. Please help support this local business ”
“ I only get to come out to Austintown about once a year for a competition. I am a school bus driver and the place I love to eat is here at Captain Arthur’s great people. Great service great food. This is a very clean establishment. Bathrooms are very clean. That’s how you know that they take good care of everything in the back cleanliness wise. ”
“ Definitely worth the drive from Pennsylvania eat here great for and friendly staff that work here ”
“ Great food and friendly staff!! It's the same as Arthur treachers!! I was so happy to have the chicken sandwich with Cole slaw and red sauce. Hushpuppies and chips the same. The fish seems to be the same I just don't eat fish. ”
“ Absolutely awesome. Even the name change but the deliciousness never changed. Staff was super nice and friendly. ”
“ I haven't been to this Arthur Treacher's restaurant since I was a kid, but the food is just as good as I remember. I complimented the crew for keeping up the quality. You won't find food sitting under the lamps getting dried out here. They make every order fresh! I've had my share of disappointments at other places, claiming to serve Arthur Treacher's original Fish and Chips that didn't even come close. Please, if you're in town, stop by and tell them I said it's well worth it! ”
“ Such a cool place! A great feeling of an old school Fish n Chips style restaurant like the ones we grew up with! Kinda like the old Arthur Treachers restaurant but better! My fish and chicken combo was perfect! Love the Cole slaw too! I hope more people support businesses like this one. ”